Matomo vs. GA4 vs. Piwik PRO [with better option]

Your choice of analytics platform can be the difference between clear insights and daily frustrations.

Matomo shines in privacy but has its limits, GA4 offers depth but can feel overwhelming, and Piwik PRO provides enterprise-grade power at a premium. Each has its perks—and its compromises.

But here’s the good news: you don’t have to choose between them. We’ve compared these platforms on privacy, usability, features, and pricing to show why more businesses are choosing Usermaven as their all-in-one analytics solution.

Let’s help you find the perfect fit.

Understanding each platform’s core offerings

Google Analytics 4 (GA4) represents Google’s latest analytics offering, but its complexity often hinders its effectiveness. While packed with features, users struggle with its steep learning curve, complex interface, and limited data retention. Privacy concerns about data sharing, manual event tracking requirements, and sampling issues at higher volumes create additional challenges. Limited customer support leaves many users navigating these complexities alone.

Piwik PRO targets enterprise clients with its privacy-focused analytics solution. However, its high pricing, starting at €10,995 annually, makes it inaccessible for many businesses. The platform requires significant technical expertise for implementation and maintenance. Despite comprehensive reporting tools, 30-minute data refresh delays and limited AI capabilities restrict its potential. Organizations need dedicated technical teams to fully utilize the platform.

Related: 11 powerful Piwik Pro alternatives

Matomo offers flexible deployment with self-hosted and cloud options, emphasizing privacy and data ownership. However, its basic feature set and manual event tracking configuration can limit effectiveness. The platform requires moderate to high technical expertise, while limited product analytics features restrict insight potential. At $24/month for 50K events, some organizations may find the price high given these limitations. That often leads teams to look for a Matomo alternative that offers easier setup, stronger automation, and deeper insights.

Usermaven represents a modern approach to analytics, combining AI-powered insights with user-friendly design. The platform offers automatic event tracking, real-time updates, and comprehensive features without requiring technical expertise. With privacy-compliant design and affordable pricing at $14/month for 100K events, Usermaven makes advanced analytics accessible to organizations of all sizes. Its automated approach and innovative features address the common pain points of traditional platforms.

Now let’s discuss each of the tools in detail so that your decision to choose between them becomes easy!

1. Privacy and data compliance

Google Analytics 4 stores data on Google’s servers and utilizes it for advertising services, raising GDPR compliance concerns. Its cookie-dependent tracking and limited data ownership model present privacy challenges. Ad blockers significantly impact data collection, potentially compromising analytics accuracy. The platform’s privacy features are limited, making it less suitable for organizations with strict data protection requirements.

Piwik PRO prioritizes privacy with EU-based data hosting and comprehensive GDPR and HIPAA compliance. While still cookie-dependent, it offers complete data ownership and custom consent forms. The platform maintains moderate resilience against ad blockers and provides privacy controls suitable for regulated industries.

Matomo offers both self-hosted and cloud options, ensuring complete data ownership and GDPR compliance. However, its cookie-dependent tracking makes it vulnerable to ad blockers, potentially affecting data accuracy. The platform provides basic consent management features and privacy controls, making it suitable for organizations prioritizing data ownership.

Usermaven combines EU-based hosting with complete data ownership and comprehensive GDPR/CCPA compliance. Its innovative cookieless tracking option and 99% accuracy against ad blockers set it apart. The platform features advanced consent management while maintaining user privacy, making it ideal for organizations seeking both robust analytics and strong privacy protection.

Feature	Usermaven	GA4	Piwik PRO	Matomo
GDPR compliance	✅	❌	✅	✅
CCPA compliance	✅	❌	✅	✅
Cookieless option	✅	❌	❌	❌
Ad blocker resistance	99%	❌	Moderate	❌
EU data hosting	✅	❌	✅	Optional

Related read: Fathom vs. GA4 vs. Usermaven

2. Implementation and ease of use

Google Analytics 4’s implementation process requires significant technical expertise and time investment. The platform demands manual event configuration and features a steep learning curve that can challenge even experienced users. With limited customer support and complex debugging tools, organizations often need dedicated analytics expertise to fully utilize GA4’s capabilities. The setup process can take days or weeks to complete properly.

Piwik PRO follows an enterprise-focused approach to implementation, requiring technical expertise for proper setup. While it offers custom tracking options and advanced debugging capabilities, the moderate learning curve demands dedicated resources. The platform compensates with premium support services, but the technical implementation can still be time-consuming for organizations without specialized staff.

Matomo as a developer-centric platform, requires technical knowledge for both self-hosted and cloud implementations. The manual configuration process and basic debugging tools can present challenges for non-technical users. While community support is available, the platform’s technical nature means organizations need development resources for successful implementation and maintenance.

Usermaven stands out with its streamlined 5-minute setup process and no-code implementation approach. The platform features automatic event tracking and a gentle learning curve, making it accessible to users of all technical levels. With dedicated support and built-in debugging tools, organizations can quickly implement and maintain their analytics without requiring specialized technical expertise.

Feature	Usermaven	GA4	Piwik PRO	Matomo
Setup time	5 minutes	Hours/Days	Days	Hours
Technical expertise	None	High	High	Moderate
Event tracking	Automatic	Manual	Manual	Manual
Learning curve	Gentle	Steep	Moderate	Moderate
Support options	Live + Email	Community	Premium	Community

3. Analytics capabilities: Attribution modeling

Google Analytics 4 offers basic multi-channel attribution capabilities with a restricted lookback window. The platform’s standard attribution models require manual setup and provide limited cross-device tracking functionality. Its basic visualization tools can make it challenging to derive meaningful insights from attribution data. While functional for basic needs, GA4’s attribution modeling lacks the sophistication required for complex marketing analysis.

Piwik PRO elevates attribution analysis with advanced options and customizable lookback windows. While still requiring manual configuration, the platform provides standard attribution models enhanced by advanced visualization capabilities. However, its cross-device tracking remains basic, potentially limiting the completeness of customer journey analysis. The platform balances sophisticated features with enterprise-level complexity.

Matomo provides basic attribution features with limited functionality. The platform’s restricted lookback window and lack of cross-device tracking capability constrain its attribution analysis potential. Standard attribution models require manual setup, and basic visualization tools make it challenging to gain comprehensive insights. The platform’s attribution capabilities are best suited for organizations with simple tracking needs.

Usermaven leads with seven comprehensive attribution models and an extensive 180-day lookback window. The platform’s AI-powered attribution system provides advanced cross-device tracking and automatic setup, eliminating manual configuration needs. With advanced visualization tools, Usermaven offers deep insights into customer journeys across multiple touchpoints. The combination of automation and sophisticated analysis makes it ideal for organizations seeking comprehensive attribution modeling without complexity.

Feature	Usermaven	GA4	Piwik PRO	Matomo
Attribution models	7 models	Basic	Basic	Basic
Lookback window	180 days	90 days	Custom	Limited
Cross-device tracking	Advanced	Limited	Basic	None
AI attribution	✅	❌	❌	❌
Setup process	Automatic	Manual	Manual	Manual
Visualization tools	Advanced	Basic	Advanced	Basic

4. Feature adoption and product analytics

GA4’s feature tracking capabilities remain at a basic level, requiring manual setup for each tracked feature. The platform offers limited adoption metrics and basic user flow analysis, making it difficult to gain deep insights into feature usage patterns. With standard reporting tools and limited retention analysis, organizations may struggle to fully understand how users interact with their products over time.

Piwik PRO offers advanced feature tracking capabilities, though it requires custom implementation. While the platform provides user flow visualization and custom reporting options, its adoption metrics remain basic. The retention analysis capabilities, while present, lack depth. The platform’s strength lies in its customization options, but this comes at the cost of implementation complexity.

Matomo’s approach to feature tracking is basic, requiring manual configuration for setup. The platform’s limited adoption data and simple user flows provide only surface-level insights into feature usage. Standard reports and limited retention data make it challenging to track long-term feature success. The platform’s capabilities best suit organizations with basic product analytics needs.

Usermaven revolutionizes feature tracking with automatic implementation and AI-powered insights. The platform provides detailed adoption metrics and advanced user journey analysis, offering a comprehensive understanding of feature usage patterns. With custom dashboards and thorough retention analysis, organizations can easily track and optimize feature performance. The combination of automation and detailed analytics makes it ideal for teams seeking deep product insights without technical complexity.

Feature	Usermaven	GA4	Piwik Pro	Matomo
Feature tracking	Automatic	Manual	Manual	Manual
Adoption metrics	Advanced	Basic	Basic	Limited
User journeys	AI-powered	Basic	Advanced	Basic
Real-time reports	✅	❌	❌	❌
Retention analysis	Advanced	Basic	Basic	Limited
Real-time events	✅	Delayed	30-min delay	Delayed

5. Pricing and value proposition

Google Analytics 4 offers a free basic version that appears attractive at first glance but comes with significant hidden costs. While the initial tier is free, organizations often face substantial expenses for implementation, training, and additional support. The limited features in the free tier frequently necessitate upgrading to GA360 for enterprise needs, leading to considerable cost escalation. The lack of included support and training means organizations must budget for these essential services separately.

Piwik PRO positions itself in the enterprise market with a significant starting price of €10,995 per year. While this price point includes comprehensive training and premium support, the initial implementation costs can be substantial. The platform offers all features without additional charges, making it easier to predict total costs. However, the high entry price point means many teams may start looking for a Piwik PRO alternative that offers more accessible pricing without adding complexity.

Matomo provides a moderate entry point at $24 per month, including 50K events. The platform offers flexibility with its self-hosted option, which can be cost-effective for some organizations. However, additional features come at extra cost, and premium support requires a separate payment. While the initial price seems affordable, organizations should consider the total cost of needed features and support services when evaluating the platform.

Usermaven delivers exceptional value with a competitive starting price of $14 per month, including 100K events. The platform stands out by including all features and full support in the base price, with no hidden costs or additional charges. The availability of a free trial allows organizations to thoroughly evaluate the platform before committing. This transparent pricing model, combined with comprehensive feature access and support, makes Usermaven the most cost-effective solution for organizations of all sizes.

Feature	Usermaven	GA4	Piwik PRO	Matomo
Starting price	$14/mo	Free	€10,995/year	$24/mo
Event allowance	100K	Unlimited*	Custom	50K
Hidden costs	None	Yes	Limited	Some
Feature access	Mostly	Limited	All	Basic
Free trial	30 days	N/A	Limited	21 days

*Subject to sampling at higher volumes

6. User journey and funnel analysis

Google Analytics 4’s journey and funnel capabilities remain basic, requiring manual setup for tracking user paths and creating funnels. While it offers standard visualization tools, the platform struggles with real-time analysis and limited cross-device tracking. The complexity of setup and delayed data updates can hinder quick decision-making and optimization efforts.

Piwik PRO elevates analysis with enterprise-grade journey mapping and custom funnel creation. However, its 30-minute data delay and manual configuration requirements present challenges. While offering advanced segmentation and detailed reporting, the platform’s complexity demands significant technical expertise for effective implementation.

Matomo provides simple journey visualization and basic funnel tools but lacks sophisticated analysis capabilities. With no cross-device tracking and limited retroactive analysis, organizations may find it insufficient for complex user behavior analysis. The platform’s basic reporting and manual setup requirements best suit organizations with straightforward tracking needs.

Usermaven revolutionizes journey and funnel analysis through AI-powered automation. The platform automatically detects user paths, suggests funnels, and provides real-time insights. With advanced cross-device tracking and unlimited segmentation options, organizations can quickly understand and optimize user behavior without technical complexity.

Feature	Usermaven	GA4	Piwik Pro	Matomo
Journey mapping	Automatic	Manual	Manual	Manual
User path analysis	AI-powered	Basic	Advanced	Basic
Funnel creation	Easy	Manual	Manual	Manual
Funnel insights/suggestions	AI-powered	❌	❌	❌
Drop-off analysis	Automatic	❌	❌	❌
Path visualization	Advanced	Basic	Advanced	Basic

Making your decision

When choosing between these platforms, consider:

1. Budget constraints
   • Usermaven offers the best value with more features at a lower price point
   • GA4 is free but has hidden costs and limitations
   • Piwik PRO targets enterprise budgets
   • Matomo has moderate pricing but limited features

2. Technical resources
   • Usermaven requires minimal technical expertise
   • GA4 needs significant technical knowledge
   • Piwik PRO requires enterprise-level expertise
   • Matomo needs moderate technical skills

3. Privacy requirements
   • Usermaven offers complete privacy compliance
   • GA4 has privacy concerns
   • Piwik PRO provides strong privacy features
   • Matomo offers good privacy controls

4. Feature needs
   • Usermaven provides comprehensive features with AI
   • GA4 offers basic features with a complex setup
   • Piwik PRO has advanced features but complex implementation
   • Matomo provides basic features with limited advanced capabilities

Conclusion

While each platform has its strengths, Usermaven emerges as the most balanced solution. It offers better pricing compared to Piwik PRO and Matomo, more features than GA4 and Matomo, and an easier implementation process than all its alternatives. 

Additionally, Usermaven excels in privacy compliance, advanced AI capabilities, and comprehensive support. For businesses seeking a modern, powerful analytics solution that combines functionality with ease of use, Usermaven is the ideal choice. 

Start your 30-day free trial today and experience the difference firsthand.

---

FAQs